
Tanya Bindernagel is the first female Adventist chaplain on active duty for the United States Army. She is currently deployed in Afghanistan.
________________________
RD: What is your current assignment in Afghanistan and how long is your deployment?
TB: I am the Battalion Chaplain for the 129th Combat Sustainment Support Battalion (CSSB) "Drive the Wedge" out of Fort Campbell, Kentucky. I am currently deployed forward in support of Operation Enduring Freedom at Camp Leatherneck, in the Helmand Province of Afghanistan. Our battalion's mission is to conduct logistical support in the southwestern region. The 129th CSSB is currently comprised of companies in different stages of the deployment cycle. These companies conduct escort missions, heavy equipment transport (military version of the semi-truck), and supply accountability and distribution. Our deployment is for 365 days-- from October 2010 until October 2011.
RD: What attracted you to military chaplaincy? What do you actually do in your role as chaplain?
TB: I was originally interested in youth and student ministries during my undergraduate time at Indiana University and somewhere during my studies I started to consider going to seminary for youth ministry so I could do it full time. At the beginning of my senior year of college, I had a co-worker enlist in the Marine Corps. I had considered the military at one point as something that might be fun to do but had set it aside as not something I would actually do. But the more I talked to my co-worker as she prepared to go to basic training, the more interested I became. Before I knew it, I was in an Army recruiter’s office (I could never get the Marine Corps to call me back). I explained my interest in the military and my interest in ministry. The recruiter, who was a Baptist lay-pastor, suggested I consider becoming a chaplain. I didn’t even know what a chaplain was but it sounded good and I agreed. The recruiter then pointed out I would have to go to seminary first, but that I could enlist as a chaplain assistant to get the military experience started and to get a feel for what being a chaplain might be like while I worked on the seminary requirement. I agreed and enlisted. I completed basic training and advanced individual training (AIT) for chaplain assistants. In 2002, I submitted my packet to become a chaplain candidate but before the packet was approved, I was deployed with a reserve unit to Germany in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom. During that time, even as a chaplain assistant, I learned more about what a chaplain actually did and realized I really enjoyed it. By the time I returned to the US, I was convinced that I wanted to be a chaplain. In 2006, after graduating from the seminary at Andrews University, I became a chaplain in the reserve. And in 2009, after leaping over what felt like an endless line of hurdles, I finally became the first Seventh-day Adventist female chaplain on active duty assigned to the 129th CSSB, 101st Sustainment Brigade, 101st Airborne Division (Air Assault) at Fort Campbell.
I am attracted to military chaplaincy because it allows me to minister in a way that is completely “outside the box.” It is incarnational ministry at its best! I am integrated into the Army as a soldier and as a special staff officer with the purpose of providing religious support and spiritual fitness opportunities in a variety of settings to a variety of ranks and positions. Most of my job involves simply being a “ministry of presence,” going where my soldiers are and doing what my soldiers do, and in that bringing God into their experience, not by force but by gentle example. It’s exactly what Jesus did – spent time with people where they were at, subtly planting and nurturing seeds until they were ready to come to him on their own terms. Much of my time is spent visiting with soldiers at work sites, motor pools, ranges, and other training and/or combat locations such as convoys, where I simply hang out with them. I also spend a lot of time counseling soldiers on a variety of issues including spiritual mentorship, relationships, work stress, battle fatigue, and post-traumatic stress. I provide chapel services, conduct Bible studies, pray over and ride on convoys, teach classes on a variety of topics, and serve as an advisor to my commander on counseling trends and spiritual fitness needs within the battalion. I also assist in traumatic events, conduct critical incident stress debriefs, and help with memorial ceremonies.
RD: What is your living arrangement at Camp Leatherneck? What is it like to live in such cramped quarters amidst such diversity?
TB: We live in what are called “relocatable buildings,” although I’m not sure how relocateable they really are because they are anchored to solid concrete foundations. Either way, it is a place of luxury compared to the tents they replaced. I share a room with five other females. There’s enough room for each of us to have our own bunk, the bottom for sleeping and the top for storing our belongings. Up until recently we had some rooms with twelve soldiers in them so I really can’t complain. My roommates include our supply officer, our supply sergeant, a support operations warrant (technical) officer, a support operations sergeant, and an information technology sergeant (computers, etc.). We all get along for the most part, although I have noticed that over the past few weeks more and more barriers have been erected to faciliate increased privacy and “alone time”.
There are all kinds of people with me from all parts of the United States, Puerto Rico, and even Nepal and China! We also work closely with Marines, airmen, British, Danish, and other armed forces, as well as with contracted civilians from all over the world. I love the diversity, although it does have its challenges and its abundance of conflicting personalities. After five months, true personalities have started to emerge and tempers have started to flare. Even so, we have become like a family, clinging to each other as we ride the ups and downs of deployment and combat; I know there isn’t anything we wouldn’t do for each other, especially in a time of crisis.
RD: You and your battalion see some painful things from day to day. How have you processed your experiences, and how have you been able to support the men and women to whom you minister?
TB: Everybody develops a coping mechanism. For some folks, its spending hours each day in the gym. For others, its movies or video games. And to some extent, we have all engaged in what they call “emotional detachment” in order to survive the long separation from family and the trials that come with working in a combat environment. I wrote it in my blog but I saw the following written in the hat of a Marine I sat next to one day as I was waiting to get my hair cut: “Stay hard and cry”. That is exactly how I have processed my experiences. I have remained tough and strong. But at the same time I have cried. In other words, I know what this job involves. I know the hard realities and the fine, fragile line we walk between life and death. But I also maintain a transparent, empathic spirit that allows me to provide genuine comfort and encouragement during times of intense pain. I am always reminded that we are in this together over here, and that we will also get through it together. When I lost two of my soldiers in an IED blast several months ago, it hurt and I cried. I was not immune to the pain of the tragedy. And in that I was able to minister to everyone else who was hurting. I support my soldiers by being a presence, walking with them through the trials in hope of triumph. It is never forced, but in the trauma and pain I provide a listening ear, quiet words, a gentle prayer, a friendly touch, spiritual wisdom, or whatever else may be helpful and appropriate.
RD: What is your impression of the Afghan civilians? What are some of the good experiences and interactions you’ve had with them?
TB: I have had minimal contact with Afghan civilians. On the road we are not permitted to stop and interact with civilians. The only interaction has been with the drivers of our host nation trucks and our interpreters, and even that has been minimal, especially since I am female.
RD: What’s it like to counsel macho men? How do they relate to you and vice versa?
TB: Counseling macho men is no different than counseling anyone else. A soldier is a soldier and a soldier is still a person regardless of gender or personality. There have been some instances where I have had to “prove” myself. Although the Army is co-ed, it is still largely male, even in the logistics units. Not long ago, I was on a convoy where I was the only female out of 35 soldiers. I have learned that it really all comes down to building relationships. I visit my soldiers and treat them all with respect. I attempt to understand and meet their needs. And as I get to know them and they get to know me, they are able to relate to me with relative ease regardless of gender.
RD: What has been the most difficult aspect of your work in Afghanistan so far? What has been the most rewarding?
TB: The most difficult thing I’ve had to do so far here in Afghanistan is escort the bodies of two of my soldiers on to a C-130 after they were killed by a command-wire improvised explosive device (CWIED). I will never forget the morning I got up at 2:30am to pray over the departing convoy. I will never forget the news that came across our convoy tracker ten hours later reporting the IED blast that cut the lives of two of my soldiers tragically short. I will never forget the trip to the mortuary affairs office where I was to escort the soldiers’ command team in to pay final respects. And I will never forget the dignified transfer ceremony where we proudly and sadly escorted the remains of both soldiers onto the airplane. In a broader sense, the most difficult aspect of my work in Afghanistan so far has been dealing with so much tragedy. Yes, the blessings flow in abundance, but that does not mean complete immunity from pain and suffering.
The most rewarding part of my job is seeing soldiers come up out of a dark place and into the light. For some this is a spiritual thing, starting without knowledge or with an incorrect knowledge of God and ending with a dynamic relationship with him that revolutionizes their life and purpose. For others this is a relationship thing, starting in a place of conflict with a spouse or child or friend and ending with a relationship repaired and solidified in a way that is enduring. For still others this is starting in a place where the things of life and war have left traumatic scars and ending in a place where the things of life and war expose an opportunity for growth and for a chance to make a positive difference in the world. I love my job. I love my soldiers. And I love the way I am able to help and serve, hopefully and prayerfully making my unit and the Army a better place to be.
RD: What is it like to be away from your family?
TB: The worst part of the deployment is the separation from family. There are moments where the separation is absolutely heartbreaking. A year is a long time, especially for my children-- a four and a two year old-- and although the days go by fast for me as I stay busy, the thoughts of all I am missing back home intrude and leave a sadness that is not easily ignored. It is an important sacrifice, but a sacrifice all the same.
RD: Some people who read this interview will have strong positions either for or against the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Is there anything you’d like to say to those people?
TB: I always like to highlight that my particular job has very little to do with my views for or against the war. I don't always agree with decisions that are made from the top but that doesn’t affect my job. My job is to provide religious support to the soldiers who, for whatever reason or conviction, have made the decision to serve their country in this capacity. My job is also to provide spiritual fitness opportunities so that when soldiers are placed in situations where they have to make those tough decisions (to pull or not to pull the trigger), they can make those decisions in good judgment and conscience. We are one of the few militaries to recognize the importance of the spiritual element in the context of war and the value of having spiritual fitness along with the physical and mental. This has more to do with the individual soldier and less to do with the actual war.
But my comments wouldn't be complete if I didn't at least note how the story most people receive in the States is not the whole story of what really happens. The news is full of stories about all the things that have not worked and about all the service members who have lost their lives, but the news rarely shows the often little and seemingly insignificant things that are being done to help the people of Afghanistan. I was in Afghanistan as a civilian in 1996 and now I am here as a soldier in 2011. I have seen both sides of the fence and know that even the worst help we can provide is better than nothing. It's not without flaws, and war is war, but it isn't as hopeless and as terrible as a lot of people think. It is a very hard war to fight because the enemy is sneaky and willing to sacrifice in ways we are not. But once again, it is not my job or even the job of my soldiers to pass judgment on whether or not the war should exist, but rather to serve God, each other and our country to the best of our ability.
__________________
Official Army Biographical Excerpt
Chaplain Tanya K. Bindernagel was born on March 1, 1979 in St. Louis Park, Minnesota and was raised in Cupertino, California. In November of 2000, Chaplain Bindernagel enlisted in the US Army Reserve as a Chaplain Assistant and was attached to the Eighth US Army Reserve (CONUS) detachment in Indianapolis, Indiana. She served there until she received her Bachelor of Arts degree in Telecommunications from Indiana University, Bloomington in May of 2001.
In summer 2002, Chaplain Bindernagel began seminary studies. She was interrupted several months later with a deployment as a Chaplain Assistant to Germany with the Reserve component of the 21st Theater Support Command in support of Operations Enduring and Iraqi Freedom. Upon redeployment, Chaplain Bindernagel transitioned into the Chaplain Candidate program where she would remain until the completion of a Master of Divinity degree in 2006 from the Seventh-day Adventist Theological Seminary at Andrews University in Berrien Springs, Michigan.
Chaplain Bindernagel reentered the US Army Reserve as a Chaplain in May 2006, serving with the 384th MP BN, Ft. Wayne, Indiana and the 766th Transportation Battalion, South Bend, Indiana. In 2007, Chaplain Bindernagel became the first Seventh-day Adventist female to receive ecclesiastical endorsement for active duty Army Chaplaincy through Adventist Chaplaincy Ministries and in February 2009 entered into active duty as a Chaplain. She is currently serving as the Battalion Chaplain for the 129th Combat Sustainment Support Battalion based out of Ft. Campbell, Kentucky deployed forward to Camp Leatherneck, Afghanistan in support of Operation Enduring Freedom, 2010-2011.
Her military education includes Basic Combat Training, Advanced Individual Training for 56M, and the Chaplain Officer Basic Leadership Course.
Her awards include: Army Overseas Ribbon, Army Service Ribbon, Armed Forces Reserve Ribbon with mobilization, Global War on Terror Service Ribbon, National Defense Service Medal, Army Reserve Component Achievement Medal, Volunteer Service Medal, Army Achievement Medal w/Oak Leaf, and Army Commendation Medal.
CH Bindernagel is married to Jonathan Bindernagel and has two children, Michael Isaac (4) and Macrina Angelyna (2). She enjoys backpacking, traveling, running, and spending time with her family.
Welcome back.
Thank you for sharing your experience. I have a family member who is training to be a chaplain in the Armed Forces, therefore I find this relevant.
This comment has been deleted because it is a personal attack. Personal attacks will not be tolerated on the Spectrum website. Thank you.
-Web Editor
More power to you, Tanya. I can only imagine the difficulty for you to be non-judgmental while providing spiritual support to soldiers with divergent views, not least about religion. I'm wondering if you hold a regular minister's credential or commissioned minister's credential.from our church in addition to your U.S. Army commission.
Paul, chaplains do not help anyone kill, as they are unarmed non-combatants.
Governments have the authority to use the sword, according to Romans 13.
Tanya is an Adventist; the Seventh-day Adventist church endorses pastors for service as chaplains. This is in keeping with the teaching of the Seventh-day Adventist church about noncombatant service. http://www.adventistchaplains.org/article.php?id=112
I have to add that here is something I find so frustrating about this site. Here's an article about a pioneer--a female Seventh-day Adventist pastor who is serving as an Army chaplain, who is away from her family right now on the battlefields of Afghanistan. Tanya talks about the joys of this ministry, about its challenges, about what called her to it. She talks about her prior experience as an enlisted chaplain assistant. She makes intriguing statements like this: "I was in Afghanistan as a civilian in 1996 and now I am here as a soldier in 2011."
But what kind of discussion does it generate? Five comments, one of which was an attack on her that had to be deleted. Other articles about the same old topics generate hundreds of comments, people making the same old tired arguments about evolution or women's ordination or their dislike of this leader or that leader.
Here's a woman putting her life in harm's way, in a heroic way, and her sacrifice is apparently irrelevant to the majority of Spectrum posters--even to those who like to argue about women in ministry. I guess she doesn't fit their model of what a woman in ministry should be. She does fit my model of a woman in ministry. Thank you, again, Tanya, for doing what you do--you make us all proud. Pro Deo et Patria!
Here are the two quotes from the article that spoke to me: "Most of my job involves simply being a “ministry of presence,” going where my soldiers are and doing what my soldiers do, and in that bringing God into their experience, not by force but by gentle example. It’s exactly what Jesus did – spent time with people where they were at, subtly planting and nurturing seeds until they were ready to come to him on their own terms." Opportunities to minister are limitless--where we are, doing what we do, planting and nurturing.
The second quote: "I have remained tough and strong. But at the same time I have cried. In other words, I know what this job involves. I know the hard realities and the fine, fragile line we walk between life and death. But I also maintain a transparent, empathic spirit that allows me to provide genuine comfort and encouragement during times of intense pain. I am always reminded that we are in this together over here, and that we will also get through it together." To me, this embodies the true spirit of the Christian church. I am proud to have Tanya represent my church and my God in this way. I don't want to just say, "Thank you for your service." I want to say thank you for giving of yourself every day, for having a deep understanding of what Christianity is really about, and for showing the character of Christ to those in Afghanistan. This is the highest calling to which any of us can aspire.
Maybe, Bill Cork, it's because this young mother has, as you say, stepped so far outside the sanctified square that she is an alien concept. Maybe a few of us think of their own who have stepped outside, away from the safety of "all stand for the next hymn" and the indoctrination of the school system, into a world where they can only trust the rhythms instilled by their own mothers.
Scandalous and shameful... She is serving in an army –the most criminal one in the world– that kill people every day...
Tanya Bindernagel,
Blessings in your role of service in the spiritual support of the military...in an imperfect world where there are "times" force is needful to protect the "less guilty.".
regards,
pat
Which is exactly why I serve... we are ALL called to put on the armor of God and to be Soldiers for Christ! My entire purpose is to be that Soldier for Christ and bring Jesus into this "criminal" organization as you call it that all may have a chance to know the Truth and to receive the salvation that God so generously gives. Jesus said to take it to all the world and I'm taking to "all the world"... to the Army and to the country of Afghanistan (which by the way is completely closed to Christianity!). Yes we have soldiers who kill but who kill in order to stop evil and to preserve life - I didn't fully understand that until I got here and saw what the Taliban does to women and children. Doesn't necessarily make the killing right but it makes a little more sense in the context of what really happens over here, something the American public at large hears very little about.
Yes I have a credentials from the denomination... a requirement before the Army will even consider someone to be a Chaplain. I had to have the credentials and the endorsement first before I could get the commission.
One more thing. Jesus told us to "go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" and to teach them to obey His commands. It wasn't a request or a suggestion, it was an order. We have no choice but to serve Him. The Gospel is intended for the whole world and a huge part of that is GOING to the whole world. And sometimes a part of that whole world isn't accessible from inside the traditional box. The Army is by in large especially in the deployment/war context not accessible from inside the traditional box. God has always worked outside the traditional box to spread His Truth and Jesus was the first example of that! Jesus ministered to beggars, prostitutes, AND soldiers... and He did it by hanging out with them, getting to know them, and most important loving them.
God told me that my place for serving Him is in the Army as a Chaplain. I have fought that calling. I have argued with it. I have run away from it. And each time, God has put me back in it. And once I committed to it, He opened the doors and I have seen more of His hand and His salvation among my soldiers than I have seen anywhere else. It is not what most people think or assume. I know I am where He wants me and as such it is always my prayer that whatever takes place in this ministry not be about political agendas or combat strategies but rather be always and only about revealing His glory and expanding His kingdom - for that is the only purpose any of us really have while on this earth regardless of the setting.
Please rather than attacking or arguing, instead pray for me and for my soldiers that they may come to know God's grace and love and salvation!
God bless you Tanya. You are remarkable and you are an inspiration! Keep up your work and minister the gospel of Jesus Christ. May your soldiers' lives continue to be touched by yours and may they then focus upon the master! Praying for you from Romania!
Dear Tanya, May God continue to richly bless, strengthen and keep you and the soldiers you are called to serve. I am so touched by the passion the Lord has given you and your great desire to serve him, even within the midst of war.
I too had a similar call to Army chaplaincy and I waited 2 years before I did something about it. I have now begun the process and I pray that all goes well.
You are a special person and I am deeply honored to have been given the opportunity to have read some of your heart.
God bless you
What a great career! What an outstanding witness! As a medic in WWII I have seen the relaxation and peace come over wounded men as soon as the chaplain stopped at their cot. Imagine that multiplied to the nth power if a woman would pray over them. I think every SDA pastor should do a tour of duty at the "Front". What an ecumenical "shot in the Arm" to sheparding.
Tom Z
God bless you and your ministry Tanya!
@Bill Cork pro deo et patria ..... please read .... Phil 3,20
Having worked as a chaplain and therapist in a VA hospital in Maryland (Trauma Recovery Service) and coming from a German background, you may understand my reluctance to justify any kind of wars. As Christians we might at least consider a more "international" or heavenly perspective if you want. From a European perspective the fascination with any kind of military service is hard to understand.
Having said that - chaplaincy is an important ministry - in any field: hospitals, prisons, businesses and even military. A ministry of presence is what I teach miisterial students as more important than ideology or dogamatics. Thus being ideologic or dogmatic towards military chaplaincy has to step behind that focus of such a ministry of presence. Therefore blessings on Tanya's ministry.
In terms of Spectrummagazine the issue of chaplaincy raises some different questions as well, though. Thus I would like to ask Tanya what her plans are beyond the military career... At least it is interesting to note that apparently it is possible to make a career as a female clergy in the (male dominated) military. As a German I learned with great interest that in the US chaplains are not payed or employed by the church (though credentials and additional endorsement come from the church). A interesting concept...
Tanya, I found this article when searching to see if women can be chaplains in the SDA church, as I am considering this as my ministry (perhaps with the military or perhaps with hospitals or other organizations.) I'm wondering if we might not be able to correspond about the way to go about this and how you accomplished it. Perhaps whoever is moderating this board can send you my email address (as it is above for purposes of posting this comment.) I look forward to hearing from you. You and your ministry are in my prayers.
Your Sister in Christ :)
Being in Afghanistan as a religious figure is a tough challenge. We will include you in our prayers.